Click here for the latest news from Albany and sign-up to receive
The [Green] Capitol Insider.
National Wildlife FoundationNew York affiliate of the National Wildlife Federation
bill ratings

BILL RATINGS 2007
Every week during the New York State Legislative Session, Environmental Advocates of New York reviews all of the bills introduced in legislative committees or on the floor of the State Senate or the Assembly. We then issue a memo that summarizes the legislation and also describes our position on measures with significant environmental impact.

The purpose of Environmental Advocates' rating system is to weight bills according to their potential impacts, either beneficial or detrimental, on New York's environment. The "Trees and Smokestacks" rating system is designed to place appropriate emphasis on each bill. At the end of the session, these weighted votes will be totaled to arrive at a final score for each legislator.
 

MEMO

SUMMARY & EVALUATION

RATING

ASSEMBLY BILL

SENATE BILL

1 National Grid Amendment A.9190 (Sweeney, et al.) S.6216a (Little)
2
Solid Waste Landfill Siting

A.1152 (Gunther)
S.227 (Larkin, et al.)
3 Nuclear Preparedness A.1370 (Brodsky, et al.)* S.251 (Morahan)
4
Bottle Bill Expander

BUDGET BILL BUDGET BILL
5 Forest Management Tax Breaks A.872 (Destito, et al.) S.1120 (Little)*
6 Small Business Energy Loans A.5494 (Weprin)*  
7 Environmental Access to Justice (SEQRA Standing) A.1435 (Bradley, et al.)* S.5182 (Morahan)
8 Green Building Construction Act A.2005b (Lupardo)* S.5442a (Marcellino)
9 Recyclables in Landfills A.3318 (Colton)*  
10 Urban Pesticide Board A.5299 (Wright)* S.1560 (Marcellino)
11 Burn Barrel Ban A.5457 (Koon)*  
12 Wetland Protection
SUPER BILL
A.7133 (Sweeney)* S.3835 (Marcellino)
13 Great Lakes Compact A.7266b (Sweeney)* S.4324b (Maziarz)
14 Smart Growth Infrastructure Act A.7335 (Hoyt)* S.4369 (LaValle)
15 Climate Change Solutions
SUPER BILL
A.7365 (Sweeney)*
A.7366 (Gianaris)*
S.5347 (Marcellino)
S.5371 (Marcellino)
16 Climate Change Task Force A.7367a (Sweeney)* S.5427a (Marcellino)
17 Community Preservation Act
SUPER BILL
A.7333 (Sweeney)* S.3836 (Marcellino)
18 Environmental Impact Reports A.2002 (Diaz R)*  
19 Green Power Purchasing A.2162 (Galef)*  
20 Green Power Purchasing   S.3855 (Marcellino)
21 Adirondack Dead Timber A.1325 (Aubertine) S.1123 (Little)
22 Waterway Right of Passage A.7230 (Hoyt) S.5792 (Flanagan)
23 Alternative Energy Systems Tax Credits A.8350 (Gordon) S.1634 (Fuschillo)*
24 Landlord Disclosure A.2742 (Lupardo)* S.1586 (Libous)*
25 Vested Right for Land Development A.6023a (Bradley) S.3852a (Flanagan)
26 Environmental Justice and Permits A.1098 (Brodsky)*  
27 Forest Tax Exemption A.1252 (Gunther) S.1056-a (Little)
28 Bottle Bill Expander
SUPER BILL
A.8044 (Sweeney) S.5850 (Marcellino)
29 Wetland Neighbor Notification A.2799 (Cusick)* S.3035 (Lanza)
30 Ballast Water A.1355 (Aubertine)*  
31 Injunctive Relief and Civil Penalties for Environmental Violations A.6903 (Gianaris and Boyland)  
32 Solar Energy System Tax Credits A.7451 (Farrell)* S.4482 (Skelos)*
33 Natural Resource Damage A.8090 (Sweeney, et al.)  
34 Petroleum Business Tax Exemption A.8886 (Cahill) S.5011 (Alesi)*
35 Hudson Valley Community Preservation Act A.7849b (Bradley)* S.6271 (Leibell)*
36 Ocean Dumping A.3320 (Colton) S.5583 (Lanza)
37 Off-Shore Easements A.7816 (Englebright) S.5528 (LaValle)
38 EPF Enhancement A.8339 (Sweeney, et al.)* S.5304 (Marcellino, et al.)*
39 Adirondack Highways A.7082 (Sayward) S.4113 (Little)
40 Watershed Rules A.8131 (Gottfried)  
41 Home Heating System and Clean Fuel Tax Credits A.7909 (Sweeney, et al.) S.5451 (Marcellino)*
42 Littering Fines A.206 (Fields, et al.) S.53 (DeFrancisco, et al.)*
43 Aquatic Invasive Species   S.959 (Maziarz, et al.)
44 LIPA Service Termination Fee Prohibition A.8304 (Englebright)* S.5975 (Johnson, O.)*
45 Efficient Outdoor Lighting A.7438 (Rosenthal, et al.)* S.4364 (Marcellino, et al.)
46 Alternative Fuels on the Thruway A.1695 (Tonko, et al.) S.1988 (Parker, et al.)
47 Electronic Waste Recycling A.2798 (Colton, et al.) S.5243 (Marcellino, et al.)
48 Brominated Flame Retardant Ban A.7977a (Sweeney,  et al.)* S.5244 (Marcellino, et al.)
49 Outdoor Wood Boilers A.1982 (Lupardo, et al.) S.3833 (Marcellino & Morahan)
50 Net Metering A.8690 (Englebright, Millman & Tonko)*  
51 Senate Article X   S.5908 (Wright)*
52 Assembly Article X A.8697 (Tonko & Silver)*  
53 Precautionary Principle A.7494 (Sweeney, et al.) S.4360 (Marcellino, et al.)
54 ATV Registration A.1306 (Aubertine) S.1122 (Little)
55 Smart Growth for a New Century A.7271a (Hoyt) S.4338a (LaValle)
56 Diesel Generator Prohibition A.7434 (Rosenthal, et al.) S.3172 (Johnson, et al.)
57 Sprawl Subsidies A.871 (Destito) S.1483 (Skelos)*
58 Lighting Efficiency Standards A.8641b (Sweeney, et al.) S.6124 (Marcellino)
59 Municipal Immunity   S.4265 (Bonacic, et al.)*
60 Cancer Mapping A.1143 (Brodsky, et al.) S.1592 (Libous, et al.)
61 Hudson River Striped Bass A.1147 (Brodsky, et al.) S.5582 (Leibell)
62 Healthy & Green Procurement A.7483a (Sweeney, et al.)  
63 Greenhouse Gases Research Program A.3414a (Magnarelli, et al.) S.6276 (Wright)
64 Green Roof Tax Credit A.5449 (Dinowitz) S.4362 (Marcellino)
65 Clean Vehicle Incentive Program A.9003 (Sweeney)  
66 Cellulosic Ethanol Production Tax Credit A.7570a (Magnarelli, et al.) S.5389 (Wright)*
67 Assembly Energy Plan A.8940 (Tonko, SIlver, Gianaris, et al.)  
68 Chatham CPF A.8217 (Gordon) S.4692 (Saland)*
69 Fishkill CPF A.7939 (Miller) S.4829 (Saland)*
70 Long Island Coastal Rights A.7584 (Alessi, et al.) S.3715 (LaValle, Trunzo)
71 DEC Greenhouse Gas Website A.9199 (Sweeney)  
72 State Agency Greenhouse Gas Audit A.9169 (Sweeney)  
73 Plastic Bag Recycling A.8810b (Sweeney, et al.) S.6253 (Marcellino)
74 Refrigerator Replacement A.5177 (Perry, et al.)* S.4531 (Golden)*
75 Congestion Pricing A.9362 (Silver, Farrell, et al.) S.6432 (Rules)


 

TREES & SMOKESTACKS RATING SYSTEM 

Legislation would be of significant benefit to help resolve a pressing problem facing New York's environment.

Legislation is likely to result in major or lasting harm to some aspect of New York's environment.

Legislation would provide substantial benefit to New York's environment.

Legislation would do substantial harm to New York's environment.

Legislation would be beneficial to some aspect of New York's environment.

Legislation would be detrimental to environmental causes in New York.


SUPER BILLS
 
Every year, a few bills are identified as environmental priorities, or "Super Bills." The Super Bills are all three-tree bills, and are included as part of lawmakers’ scores in our sister organization's (EPL/Environmental Advocates) Voters' Guide, even if the legislation does not reach the floor of the Senate or Assembly for a vote. Click here for more info.