For Immediate Release:
October 25, 2001
For Information, Contact:
Jeff Jones: 518-462-5526 ext. 233
(Albany, N.Y.) Evaluating a legislative session that began with hope, degenerated into distrust and finally had to address tragedy, EPL/Environmental Advocates today released its annual Voters' Guide: An Insider's Guide to the Environmental Record of New York State's Legislature and Governor. The Guide scores lawmakers on their environmental voting records and analyzes the successes and failures of each year's session.
Despite some important successes and many disappointing failures, the tragic Sept. 11th attacks on the World Trade Center obviously marked the end of any attempt at a normal year in Albany. EPL/Environmental Advocates notes that nine pieces of legislation impacting the environment had passed both the Senate and Assembly before this week's session. Several of these, including an important public health bill to reform the Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System (SPARCS) (A.1644/S.3341), the Dark Skies bill to reduce nightime light pollution and save energy (A.5352a/S.3386b), and a bill to fast-track the siting of power plants that meet stringent environmental standards (A.8952/S.5443), highlighted the session. The SPARCS bill was signed into law by Gov. George Pataki in early September. The power plant bill reforming Article X of the state Public Service Law was signed by the Governor in late August, and was just amended this week to include minimum water withdrawals (A9425/S.5778). The Dark Skies bill, however, still awaits Pataki's signature. EPL/Environmental Advocates urges the Governor to sign the legislation, which will reduce energy consumption in New York through regulation of permanent outdoor lighting.
Only one bill opposed by EPL/Environmental Advocates passed both houses of the Legislature. It authorizes New York's membership in the Interstate Pest Control Compact (A.8596/S.3546), which could lead to state funds being used for pest management efforts that rely on chemical methods of pest control and ill-considered goals of pest "eradication." The organization urges the Governor to veto this bill.
"This has been an overwhelmingly sad season for all New Yorkers," said EPL/Environmental Advocates Executive Director Val Washington, "and the environmental community is rallying to help rebuild and to find opportunities to create hopes and protect our future. We believe that continuing to move forward with the state's environmental agenda is an important part of that process and so we are calling on the Governor to appropriate at least $150 million from the Environmental Protection Fund (EPF) account. It is our sincere belief that New Yorkers continue to value a clean environment and a strong natural heritage as priorities. These values have been largely achieved through the EPF since it was established in 1993."
The EPF is a dedicated fund that draws from several sources including the real estate transfer tax and the sale of open space license plates. There is more than enough money in the account to fund projects that were agreed on earlier in the year by the Governor and the Legislature. For the first time since 1993, New York is without funds to purchase wild forest lands from willing sellers. For many New Yorkers, the state's wilderness and public parks have been an important place for gathering with family and friends, and renewing our spirits in these troubled times. Many other important programs, from waterfront redevelopment to landfill closure to recycling depend on the EPF and must not be abandoned.
For his work in support of efforts to control power plant emissions that cause acid rain and asthma, and his strong support of cleaning PCBs from the Hudson River, EPL/Environmental Advocates recognized Attorney General Eliot Spitzer with its Public Official of the Year award. "Using all the tools at his disposal and the full symbolic force of his office, Attorney General Eliot Spitzer has championed New York's environment and, in doing so, expanded his work beyond the state's borders, recognizing that pollution knows no political boundaries," Washington said.
The group gave its Green Courage award to the many environmental professionals at the state Department of Environmental Conservation who have spent decades doing the ground level scientific research that led to the Environmental Protection Agency's landmark decision to dredge PCBs from the Hudson River. "Even though they must largely work outside the public eye which means their dedication goes unheralded it is very much appreciated by those of us involved in the Hudson River PCB issue," Washington said. "We say thanks' to the hard-working environmental professionals who helped win a victory on the Hudson this year."
EPL/Environmental Advocates released the Voters' Guide in the state Capitol. Copies of the Guide are available by calling 1-800-SAVE-NYS. The complete guide, including charts of lawmakers' scores and links to bill memos and legislation is available on the web in our 2001 Voters' Guide .
30
EPL/Environmental Advocates tabulates legislators scores based on their votes on important
environmental legislation. The rating system weights bills according to potential impact, either
beneficial or detrimental, to New York's environment. Only bills that reached the floor for a vote
were counted in this years scoring (59 bills in the Assembly; 15 bills in the Senate). The score
reflects the percentage of the time a lawmaker casts a correct environmental vote. For a full listing of Senate and Assembly scores, visit our 2001
Voters' Guide. Senate
High Scores:
Republicans:
Low Scores:
Republicans:
Assembly
High Scores:
Democrats:
Republicans:
Low Scores:
Republicans:
2001 Voters' Guide
Senate and Assembly High and Low Scores
Democrat Average Score: 79
Republican Average Score: 68
Democrats:
95- Duane
91- Breslin
Connor
Hassell-Thompson
Montgomery
Oppenheimer
Paterson
Schneiderman
90- Onorato
90- Goodman
82- LaValle
Leibell
81- Padavan
Democrats:
25- Espada
67- Kruger
Mendez
68- Gonzalez
Santiago
69- Markowitz
Smith, A.
57- Saland
Seward
59- Libous
Maltese
Meier
Nozzolio
Wright
Democrat Average Score: 94
Republican Average Score: 86
100- Englebright
Glick
Weinstein
98- DiNapoli
Dinowitz
Eddington
Gordon
Lafayette
Luster
Pretlow
Stringer
Sweeney
98- Ferrara
95- Alfano
Murray
O'Connell
94- Thiele, Jr.
93- Barra
Herbst
Ravitz
Spano
Straniere
92- Boyle
Democrats:
48- Bragman
77- Smith
74- Warner
77- Errigo
Little