Bill MemosA.9598 / S.8851

Closing the Tropical Hardwood Loophole in Government Purchasing

We support this bill

Summary

This legislation amends state finance law to close a loophole in existing restrictions on government purchasing of tropical hardwoods.

Explanation

Tropical deforestation is a major source of climate pollution. In 2024, tropical regions lost  over 16 million acres of rainforest, generating 3.1 gigatons of greenhouse gas emissions, roughly the equivalent of nine times New York State’s annual greenhouse gas emissions. Currently, New York State purchases and uses lumber and wood products made from tropical hardwood species at the heart of the deforestation crisis. In order to protect tropical forests, and by extension their ability to protect against climate change, we must move away from these purchases.

The Tropical Hardwood Loophole Closure bill strengthens existing restrictions on government purchasing of tropical hardwoods by expanding the list of trees covered. Original restrictions passed in 1991 have a loophole that doesn’t cover tree species that are key in the fight against deforestation globally. Two of the most impactful species not currently included in restrictions are ekki and greenheart.

Unsustainable and often illegal logging has continued to devastate tropical rainforests, which have shrunk by an area more than twice the size of California since 2000. Logging plays a key role by introducing roads that facilitate deforestation, leaving forests degraded and more vulnerable to forest fires, whether natural or deliberately set by humans to clear land. The resulting deforestation and degradation destroys important habitats, ecosystems, and carbon sinks.

Closing a harmful loophole will protect forest ecosystems and help mitigate the climate crisis, while saving taxpayer dollars by prioritizing more affordable, locally-sourced products.

Our Rating System

The “Trees and Smokestacks” rating system is designed to place appropriate emphasis on each bill. Our memo process is a trusted tool and resource for legislators and staff, as well as to those interested in the legislative proposals of our state government.

Superbill
Selected by an advisory group of statewide environmental organizations, this bill is one of our highest priorities.
Major Benefit
Passing this bill is a high priority. We strongly support it because it will have a major positive impact.
Substantial Benefit
We strongly support this bill because it will have a substantial positive impact.
Beneficial
We support this bill because it will have a positive impact.
Detriment
This bill will have a negative impact and should not pass.
Substantial Detriment
We strongly oppose this bill because it would have a substantial negative impact.
Major Detriment
Defeating this bill is a high priority. It would have a major detrimental impact.